Still Here, Still Burbling Along…

I am having a pretty horrible week, between receiving more bad news from a doctor about my continuing neck and shoulder pain, and stupidly getting myself into a single-vehicle car accident that has left me with a very badly dented rear bumper. But yes, despite these problems, I am still working on my OER textbook about the metaverse. Here’s a sample of chapter two, which is all about Second Life:

Here’s the text, in case you don’t want to squint at the screen capture above:

In many ways, this chapter is both the easiest and the hardest one to write for this entire book. It is the easiest to write, because of the nearly two decades of experience I have had in Second Life since I first set foot in the platform in March 2007. In that time, I have created and embodied a small army of avatars (as I mentioned in the Preface), built and furnished homes, explored other people’s creations, made friends and acquaintances from around the world, took part in fantasy and historical roleplay, and attended countless events, ranging from conferences to concerts. However, that same lived experience makes it harder for me to write about Second Life, because it makes it more difficult to step outside of my biases toward this virtual world, and look at SL from a detached, critical perspective.

What most casual observers don’t understand about Second Life, which has now been operating for over 23 years, is that it still exists, and that is still is a very profitable endeavour for Linden Lab, the company founded in 1999 by Philip Rosedale. Wagner James Au, in his book The Making of Second Life, writes memorably about those humble first days:

“Building the metaverse wasn’t even the company’s main goal when it began operations in 1999, in a warehouse on Linden Street, a narrow alley in San Francisco’s Hayes Valley. Like many parts of the city during the Internet’s first boom times, the street teetered between gentrification and drug-addled squalor. On one end of Linden were upscale restaurants serving the arrogant young mandarins of dot-com excess; on the other was an unattended parking lot with a clientele who often slept in their cars. Linden Lab’s immediate neighbors were wholly appropriate for the world that would eventually emerge from their servers: a dubiously grungy auto body garage and a fetish boutique.” (Au, 2008 p. 13)

I will probably continue to drop bits and pieces as I continue to write. Obviously, I won’t be posting to this blog as often as I used to, which is understandable. I just wanted to let you know that I’m still here.


P.S. Yes, I found and fixed the small typo in the screen capture, in the transcribed text!

P.P.S. Oops, wrong page number in my citation! Corrected.

PART TWO OF TWO: I Review Anthropoligist Tom Boellstorff’s Coming of Age in Second Life

NOTE: Have you read part one of this two-part series? I review two other 2008 books about Second Life here, and talk about how well they’ve held up since publication:

PART ONE OF TWO: I Review Two 2008 Books About Second Life—What’s Changed in 18 Years? What’s Stayed the Same?

Boellstorff, T. (2008). Coming of age in Second Life : an anthropologist explores the virtually human. Princeton University Press.


As I mentioned in my previous blogpost, Tom Boellstorff, a cultural anthropologist at the University of California, Irvine, wrote this academic book in 2008, after conducting an anthropological study of Second Life and its residents. The time period of Tom’s anthropological fieldwork, which forms the basis of this book, ran from June 3rd, 2004 to January 20th, 2007 (p. 7), a period he refers to as the “coming of age” of Second Life as a virtual world, when it grew from 5,000 to ten million resident accounts (p. 83).

Boellstorff stated his goals for this academic monograph as follows (p. 24):

One goal of this book is substantive: to provide an ethnographic portrait of Second Life. Another is methodological: to demonstrate the potential of ethnography for studying virtual worlds. A third goal is theoretical: to contribute toward a better understanding of virtual worlds in all their constantly transforming complexity.

While I do seem to remember that I had, some time in the past, dipped my nose here and there into sections of Tom’s book, I had not really had an opportunity to read through the entire work until this week (thank you to my university for approving my research and study leave!). So here is my review of Tom’s book, along with some quotes which I quite liked.

This is a structured, nine-chapter academic work, which Tom recommends you read in order as he builds his arguments. The book includes a glossary, a notes section, an extensive bibliography, and a professionally-compiled index—all features which were greatly appreciated by this librarian!

Sticky notes galore in my university library’s copy of Tom’s book!

There’s so many great insights that I sticky-noted, but I’m going to start off with a quote from his final chapter, The Virtual (p. 217):

Culture in virtual worlds may be monumental in its own way, but as speaking did not disappear with the emergence of text, so the actual world will not become irrelevant as it becomes possible to live parts of our lives online. At hand is not a Virtual Age that sweeps the actual aside, but an Age of Techne in which there is continuity and change. There is continuity because humans are virtual whenever they engage in techne: “the virtual is essential to the real” (Poster 2001:127). The story of Prometheus describes one mythic moment when humans, receiving the gift of techne, became fully human for the first time. Since humans are always crafting themselves through culture, they have always been virtual (Clark 2003). The virtual is the anthropological [emphasis Boellstorff’s]. This makes it possible to study virtual worlds with the same flexible, underdetermined ethnographic tools used to study human cultures in the actual world.

The Age of Techne is a theme throughout this book, the term Boellstorff uses to describe the technology of the current information age is which we live (p. 21). Later, on p. 38, he states:

In this discussion and throughout this book, I might be seen to be trying to have it both ways; I claim that notions of the virtual and of techne are in one sense as old as humanity, and in another sense I claim that something very new is happening in virtual worlds. This is intentional. It is crucial to keep in mind the history shaping the present moment, while also identifying how that present moment is not reducible to its history. What makes virtual worlds different from all hitherto existing forms of virtuality is that techne can take place inside them [emphasis Boellstorff’s], rather than solely in the actual world to produce them: “where most tools produce effects on a wider world of which they are only a part, the computer contains its own [virtual] worlds in miniature” (Edwards 1990:109). Techne makes wood and ideas into a newspaper, but techne not only makes silicon and ideas into a virtual world; techne can take place within that created world itself. In virtual worlds, techne produces a gap between actual and virtual in the realm of the virtual [emphasis Boellstorff’s]. Swallowing their own ontological tails, virtual worlds for the first time allow techne to become recursive, providing humans with radically new ways to understand their lives as beings of culture as well as physical embodiment.

As you can see from these two excerpts, Boellstorff is writing for an academic audience, so it might be a tough slog for those of you who are more used to reading mass-market works written for the general public, but it’s well worth unpacking his ideas! Virtual worlds created by techne (i.e, the act of software programming), can in themselves become arenas for techne (i.e creating a house in Second Life)! Indeed,this has been one of the primary reasons for the initial and continued success of Second Life: its ability to be a blank, three-dimensional canvas for people to be creative, and build anything they can imagine.

On page 25, Tom writes:

Drawing upon the work of a range of scholars of technology and society, I will develop a theory of this virtual worldview as techne, and of the person who engages in techne not just as homo faber (“man the maker”) or homo ludens (“man the player”), but above all as homo cyber. The human online, the virtual human. In using the term “techne,” I will draw upon a philosophical distinction between knowledge (episteme) and technology or art (techne), examining how virtual selfhood is becoming predicated on the idea that people can craft their lifeworlds through intentional creativity.

On page 29, he makes a clear distinction is his defnition of homo cyber, arguing that virtual worlds make us more human rather than post-human:

While some see virtual worlds as marking the emergence of the posthuman, through terms like homo cyber I argue that the forms of selfhood and sociality characterizing virtual worlds are profoundly human. But while the emergence of virtual worlds “does not necessarily mean the end of the human . . . we need to see the human as re-configured and organized differently” (Nayar 2004:21). This is one meaning of the phrase “virtually human”—in virtual worlds, we are not quite human. The relationship between the virtual and the human is not a “post” relationship where one term displaces another; it is a relationship of coconstitution. Far from it being the case that virtual worlds herald the emergence of the posthuman, in this book I argue that it is in being virtual that we are human [emphasis Boellstorff’s].

Another theme that runs throughout the book is that of creationist capitalism, described by Boellstorff as “a mode of capitalism in which labour is understood in terms of creativity, so that production is understood as creation.” (p. 206). He goes on to write (pp. 207-208):

Creationist capitalism draws structuring principles from the individualistic ethos of contemporary capitalism—specifically its Silicon Valley variant, which can be termed the “Californian Ideology” (Barbrook and Cameron 2001; see also Turner 2006). Given that Linden Lab was based in California and its CEO, Philip Rosedale, grew up in San Diego, it is not surprising that Second Life was particularly shaped by assumptions of this ideology, which “has emerged from a bizarre fusion of the cultural bohemianism of San Francisco with the high-tech industries of Silicon Valley. . . . [T]he Californian ideology promiscuously combines the free-wheeling spirit of the hippies and the entrepreneurial zeal of the yuppies. This amalgamation of opposites has been achieved through a profound faith in the emancipatory potential of the new information technologies” (Barbrook and Cameron 2001:364).

This ideology, by no means limited to California, is an economic model of “prosumption” where capitalist subjects produce what they consume, turning consumption into a form of production (Toffler 1980).

And again, another reason for Second Life’s longevity (and profitability!) is its ability to allow residents (who are themselves consumers) to create and sell goods and services to other residents. For example, an SL user can purchase textures from an in-world store, apply them to furniture she creates, and then vend that chair or table to another user. Linden Lab’s November 2003 decision to give creators the intellectual property rights to their creations (p. 214) was a key decision to enable the explosion of creationist capitalism across the grid. (I particularly loved Tom’s quoting of “the free-wheeling spirit of the hippies and the entrepreneurial zeal of the yuppies;” to me, this description perfectly encapsulates Second Life’s ethos!)

Now, I am going to jump around a bit within the book, talking about other sections I enjoyed. For example, on page 102 I was amused when Tom compared SL residents complaining about lag being equivalent to real-life people complaining about the weather. Accurate! In a further discussion of the concept of lag, I came across the following, highly interesting fact (p. 103):

In the context of Second Life, lag originated in the truly immense amount of information represented by its land, the objects on that land, and the avatars inhabiting that land. By early 2007 there was by one estimate about one petabyte (a million gigabytes) of data in Second Life. At that point, were all of the books in the Library of Congress digitized (about 30 million volumes), it would have been equivalent to only about 2 percent of the data stored inside Second Life.

I would dearly love to see this assertion updated with current statistics for both Second Life and the Library of Congress, to see how it has changed over time! Alas, I do not have the time to do this research myself (I have my hands full as it is!).

There’s also a lengthy discussion of the AFK (Away From Keyboard) phenomenon in Second Life and its various meanings (pp. 106-112), ending with the following section:

Residents sometimes explicitly scheduled mundane actual-world activities like laundry to coincide with events in Second Life, so that they could run back and forth to the washing machine: as one resident emphasized, “AFK works so well because people do not know what we are doing [in the actual world].” Residents sometimes said they wished they could “go AFK” in the actual world to escape uncomfortable situations, but knew this was not possible: “no one ever says ‘AFK’ in real life.” Such conscious uses of AFK reflect the consequentiality and durability of the virtual/actual binarism: the boundary between virtual and actual is constituted and reinforced by movements between them. Like lag, AFK reveals how virtual worlds are places in their own right, temporally linked to the actual world but constantly at risk of falling out of synch. Indeed what I term the “AFK test” provides one of the clearest means for identifying virtual worlds: if you can go “AFK” from something, that something is a virtual world. [Emphasis mine].

I also appreciated Tom’s discussion of the use of the word avatar to describe Second Life users, as well as his discussion of alts (alternate avatars) on pp. 128-134. Here’s a sample quote from page 128:

Throughout this book I have been referring to the virtual embodiments of persons as avatars, a term used in many online worlds. This Sanskrit word originally referred to the incarnation of a Hindu god (particularly Vishnu). With reference to cybersociality, the term was probably first used in the virtual worlds Habitat and Ultima IV in the mid-1980s, as well as in Neal Stephenson’s 1993 science fiction novel Snow Crash (Morningstar and Farmer 1991; Stephenson 1993:470). While “avatar” (“avie” or “av” for short) historically referred to incarnation—a movement from virtual to actual—with respect to online worlds it connotes the opposite movement from actual to virtual, a decarnation or invirtualization.

Among other topics, Boellstorff discusses the popularity of Second Life among various communities, such as the furries, queer people, and those with autistim and/or ADHD. I’m not going to quote the sections, because this blogpost is already reaching War and Peace length; I would advise you to obtain your own copy of Tom Boellstorff’s book, and read it yourself!

Even as a almost-nineteen year resident of Second Life (in one avatar or another), I gained some excellent insights from reading this book, and I can recommend it highly. It provides a valuable snapshot of a crucial time period in SL’s history, and Tom Boellstorff’s commentary on Second Life, and its cultures and idiosyncrasies, has stood up very well in the 18 years since this academic monograph was published.


P.S. To my surprise and delight, Tom Boellstorff was kind enough to comment on my first blog post of this two-part series, offering to meet up in Second Life and answer any questions I had. So you might soon see a follow-up blogpost, with a Q&A session with the author himself! It’s great to hear Tom is still active in Second Life.

P.P.S. I also did write up a blogpost about another of Boellstorff’s research projects here, as well as another blogpost about moving his Digital Cultures course into Second Life during the pandemic.

Dr. Tom Boellstorff. Photo credit: Steve Zylius/UCI

Generative AI Update: Comparing ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini while Researching the Metaverse Characteristics of Social VR Platforms

NOTICE: In this blogpost, I go into sometimes great detail about how these three generative AI tools work, comparing them in two ways:

– comparing how these tools work with the exact same text prompt; and
– comparing how they worked in August 2025 versus February 2026.

There’s an executive summary (Section 4) at the very bottom of this long, loooong blog post if you just want to skip to the highlights, and ranking.

If you need an introduction or a refresher, you might want to read this blogpost first: An Introduction to Artificial Intelligence in General, and Generative AI in Particular, which includes slides from lectures I gave on the topic in November and December of 2025.

SECTION 1: Introduction

In his 2024 book Co-Intelligence (still my go-to layperson’s guide to generative AI), Ethan Mollick says that one of the best ways to determine how well a particular generative AI tool works is to ask it questions about a subject that you already are an expert in. Why? Because it will be much easier for you, the human expert in the topic, to find errors and hallucinations in the answers.

Since last summer, I have been typing the exact same prompt into the “big three” general-purpose GenAI tools Ethan recommends: OpenAI’s ChatGPT, Anthropic’s Claude, and Google Gemini. I have been meaning to write a blogpost about my experiences with this first round of testing since September, but I have been too occupied with my paying job as an academic librarian to find an opportunity to do so—until now. (Please note that I have been using an em-dash, correctly, for many years before generative AI came along!)

So, today I decided to redo my original text prompt, using the latest versions of these three GenAI tools as outlined by Ethan in the latest edition of his AI Guide, which has posted to his Substack newsletter on Feb. 17th, 2026 (here’s a link).

I consider his advice to be quite valuable, as he seems to spend a lot of time working with the most popular and powerful GenAI tools, and keeping on top of the changes and advances in the technology. In this newest edition of his AI Guide, he discusses the shift from chatbots (where you have a conversation with the tool) to agents (where you give a specific, defined task with instructions to the tool, and it goes away and does the task and returns with results).

In all cases, the initial text prompt is the following:

What are some characteristics common to all metaverse platforms? How do these characteristics apply to social VR platforms? Please give me a chart comparing these characteristics for the most popular social VR platforms.

Please note that I have deliberately given the task of defining “popular,” and picking the social VR platforms, over to the generative AI tool (and I got some rather interesting results back!). Because I consider myself an expert on social VR and the metaverse, I should be able to spot inaccuracies, errors, or outright hallucinations in the responses I get back from these GenAI tools. In the next section (section 2), I compare and contrast the results I received from the above text prompt from:

  • Claude by Anthropic
  • ChatGPT by OpenAI
  • Gemini by Google

All three of these tools come with different versions. In all cases, I will use the most powerful version recommended by Ethan Mollick in his latest AI Guide I linked to above (but please note that in at least one case, I had made a mistake and not selected the correct option, as you will see below with Claude in Sections 2 and 3):

  • Claude Opus 4.6 Extended Thinking
  • ChatGPT 5.2 Thinking
  • Gemini 3.0 Pro Deep Research

In addition, in section 3 of this long blogpost, I will very briefly compare and contrast the results I received when I first ran this text prompt through all three GenAI tools on August 7th, 2025, with what I received when I ran them again on Feb. 18th, 2026.

All comparison charts in the February 2026 results in sections 2 and 3 will include some quick stats in a small table under each generative AI tool discussed, namely:

  • the number of characteristics common to all metaverse platforms (and their names); and
  • the number of social VR platforms in the comparison chart (and their names).

Section 4, the final section, contains my overall thoughts after spending a day working with these tools, and a ranking of how well I think these GenAI tools accomplished the given task.


SECTION 2: Comparing Searches Done Feb. 18th, 2026

Feb. 18th, 2026: Claude Opus 4.6 (and Cowork)

First up is Claude. I did this prompt two ways: once via the chatbot interface on the Claude website, and a second time using the Claude app and the new Cowork agent feature. (I was prompted to download and install the Claude app on my Mac, and authenticate using my email address.) First, the chatbot version:

This first report I got back compared eight metaverse characteristics between eight platforms:

8 Metaverse Characteristics8 Social VR Platforms
Persistent Virtual Environments
Real-Time Interactivity
User Identity/Avatars
Social Presence & Co-Experience
User-Generated Content
Virtual Economy
Cross-Platform Accessibility
Interoperability
VRChat
Rec Room
Meta Horizon Worlds
Resonite
Second Life
Spatial
ChilloutVR
NeosVR

Well, right off the bat, I see some problems. First, Second Life is not social VR. Second, it included both Resonite and NeosVR (although Claude told me, “I included both since NeosVR still has historical relevance, but noted it as legacy since the core team transitioned to Resonite”). However, that isn’t a good enough reason to include it in the table.

Then, I turned to the Claude app (which was suggested to me when I did the first text prompt above, so I downloaded and installed it on my MacBook Pro). Then I selected the Cowork (agent) tab along the top three tabs as suggested by Ethan, and I entered the exact same text ptompt:

After beavering away for a few minutes, it gave me the following result:

And when I click on the Open in Firefox button, I get this neatly formatted table (I’m not crazy about the chosen colour scheme, but that’s a minor quibble). It looks good at first:

However, the output, which might look impressive at first, is only as good as the quality of the sources used in its research. If the good information is locked behind a paywall (and therefore, not able to be scraped to add to its knowledge base), then the GenAI tool will use freely-available sources on the web, which can vary quite a bit in quality! There is an acronym in computer science called GIGO: Garbage In, Garbage Out, and I am reminded of this when I decide to take a closer, more critical look at the six sources listed.

All of them were non-academic sources, mostly generic market overviews from websites that I had never heard of before. The six sources included my own list of metaverse platforms on this blog (which is just a list, and doesn’t give any details about the platforms). While I’m flattered they included me, I expected something…more. And I absolutely hated that they mentioned cryptocurrencies, blockchain, DAOs, and NFTs, and included Somnium Space and Decentraland in the resulting table. While Somnium Space is social VR, Decentraland in absolutely not, and I have made my opinions on blockchain-based metaverse platforms very clear in the past on this blog.

8 Metaverse Characteristics6 Social VR Platforms
Persistence
Immersion & Presence
User-Generated Content
Built-In Economy
Social Interaction
Interoperability
Digital Ownership
Decentralized Governance
VRChat
Meta Horizon Worlds
Rec Room
Engage VR
Decentraland
Somnium Space

In fact, I was so dissatisfied with this report that I went back into the Claude Cowork app, and added a qualifier, and made sure that I had turned on Extended Thinking! (I’m almost positive I did that the first time around, but maybe I forgot, and unfortunately, once you’ve done your prompt, the results don’t tell you what modes you used in asking the original question.)

Only to get pretty much the same result: a pretty table with only six websites listed as sources! So much for being more specific and asking for Extended Thinking.

10 Metaverse Characteristics6 Social VR Platforms
Persistence
Immersive 3D Environments
User Identity & Avatars
Real-Time Social Interaction
User-Generated Content
Economy & Monetization
Cross-Platform Access
Scalability & Concurrency
Safety & Moderation
Interoperability
VRChat
Rec Room
Meta Horizon Worlds
Resonite
ChilloutVR
Engage VR

While better thatn the previous round, I am actually disappointed in the results I received from Claude Cowork. But read on; in section 3, I have an update on what I think went wrong here!

Feb. 18th, 2026: ChatGPT 5.2 Thinking

Next, I turned to OpenAI’s ChatGPT, using the ChatGPT 5.2 Thinking mode suggested by Ethan:

And I got back the following table. comparing six social VR platforms on ten metaverse characteristics:

While the resulting table might not be as pretty as the one produced by Claude Opus 4.6 Cowork, I appreciate that there are actual citations which you can hover over and click through to actually see the source material behind the comparison chart entries (and not just a list of websites checked, tacked on to the end). Also, ChatGPT seems to have checked a lot more sources than Claude, and made some sort of attempt to find authoritative sources (often, from the metaverse product’s own online documentation, as shown in this example).

10 Metaverse Characteristics6 Social VR Platforms
Shared Multi-User Spaces
Avatars/Embodied Identity
Real-Time Voice/”Hangout” Core Loop
Persistence (Account, Inventory)
User-Generated Worlds
In-World Creation Tools
Scripting
Economy & Monetization
Cross-Platform Access
Safety Governance
VRChat
Rec Room
Meta Horizon Worlds
Bigscreen Beta
Spatial
Resonite

Overall, I think that ChatGPT 5.2 Thinking gave me a better answer than Claude…but as we will see later on, it doesn’t compare to the best results I got from my day of testing and retesting. Let’s move on to the third of Ethan Mollick’s recommended, general-purpose GenAI tools, Google’s Gemini:

Feb. 18th, 2026: Gemini 3 Pro (first without, and then with, Deep Research)

The first go-round, I selected Gemini 3 Pro mode, as Ethan suggested:

And I got a resulting table comparing three social VR platforms across seven characteristics:

7 Metaverse Characteristics3 Social VR Platforms
Core Philosophy
Visual Style
Creation Tools
Hardware Access
Target Audience
Economy
“Metaverse” Strength (?!)
VRChat
Rec Rooom
Meta Horizon Worlds

I was so unhappy with this first Gemini result that I redid the prompt, this time making sure that I turned on the Deep Thinking mode, just to see if I would get better results, or even some actual citations to sources used:

Wow, what a difference!!

This time around, the task took a lot longer than either Claude or ChatGPT, and it included what appears to be extremely detailed feedback on what was happening behind the scenes (this seems to be turned on by default, and I’m not certain if this mode could have been enabled on Claude or ChatGPT):

And the report I got back was worth the longer wait:

And, at the end, not one but three comparison charts!

Here’s the quick stats, from all three tables in the final report (and notice how technical many of these “metaverse characteristics” are, compared to the other results!):

12 Metaverse Characteristics5 Social VR Platforms
Engine Core
Scripting Language
Persistence Type
Asset Pipeline
Audio Engine
Economic Model
Currency
Identity System
Tracking Support
Instance Cap
Network Model
Culling Tech
VRChat
Rec Room
Roblox
Meta Horizon Worlds
Resonite (only mentioned in one table)

SECTION 3: Comparing August 2025 Prompt Results with the February 2026 Ones

I also wanted to compare the results I when I did the testing last year (August 7th, 2025) with the results I got today (Feb. 18th, 2026) with all three GenAI tools. This was very enlightening.

Then Versus Now: Claude

You will understand why I was so disappointed with today’s results, when you see what the results were when I did the same prompt last year (dated August 7th, 2025):

The report I got back was extremely detailed, with actual citations to sources! I still don’t understand why I got such dramatically different—and worse—results. The difference is so astounding to me that I began to wonder if I had done something wrong this time around.

It was then that I realized that I had literally forgotten to turn on Research mode in the left-hand drop-down menu (previously, I had only had Web Search mode turned on):

So I went to check the Claude app, to see if there was that option available, and, of course, it was there—but under the Chat tab, not the Cowork tab!! So perhaps Cowork still has some user interface bugs to work out. Perhaps sending everything to an agent isn’t the better option; certainly, not in this case!!

Once I had selected both Research and Web Search from the left drop-down menu, and Opus 4.6 Extended from the right drop-down menu, I hit send and waited…until I got a message that I had used up all my credits on my $20-a-month plan!!!

AAAAAAAAAAAAAARGH!!!!

By this point, I was so frustrated with Claude that I simply exited the app. I had had enough frustration for one day.

The next morning, February 19th, 2026, after my daily credits reset at 6:00 pm, I once again tried my prompt with Claude Opus 4.6 Extended Thinking, with both Research and Web Search turned on (using the Gemini app I had installed on my Mac, as opposed to the web version; they appear to be identical in terms of features).

Right off the bat, I got a better response (and Claude even remembered that I was going to working on an OER about the metaverse!):

Again, similar to Google Gemini, I had a bit of wait while Claude did its thing. I actually preferred that Gemini actually gave better descriptions of what it was doing while it was going about its task, as opposed to…well, no updates from Claude other than me sitting and staring at an animated cursor!

Ten minutes later, I got the detailed report I wanted in the first place, and which Claude Cowork stubbornly refused to give me:

The response back included a concise summary taken from the sources examined:

The final report included citations to the academic literature (which I could hover over and click on to go to the source, see the red arrow below), and it cited experts in the field such as Matthew Ball and Tim Sweeney. It’s pretty much all I wanted, and it compares quite favourably to the similarly detailed report from Google Gemini, in the previous section. I am happy.

And this was the only report which had a listing of metaverse characteristics, separate from the ones used in the social VR platforms comparison chart:

Here’s the quick stats from the comparison chart. As you can see, there are some problems here, with the inclusion of platforms which are clearly not social VR (e.g. Second Life) and platforms that no longer exist (Altspace shut down on March 10th, 2023). These sort of mistakes make we wonder about the accuracy and currency of the report overall.

9 Metaverse Characteristics9 Social VR Platforms
Persistence
Synchronous Real-Time
Massive Scale/Concurrency
Cross-Platform Access
Virtual Economy
User-Generated Content
Interoperability
Avatar/Identity Systems
Immersive 3D/Spatial Computing
Open Standards/Decentralization
Spanning Physical-Digital
Ethical Goivernance/Accessibility
VRChat
Horizon Worlds (note: old name used)
Rec Room
Resonite
ChilloutVR
AlspaceVR (was shut down)
Second Life (not social VR!)
Roblox
Fortnite (not social VR!)

Then Versus Now: ChatGPT

An interesting difference between the August 2025 report from ChatGPT and today’s report is this: in last year’s report, for whatever reason, the tool asked me a follow-up question to clarify what was wanted (I did use the Deep Research feature in the 2025 report, as well):

Based on that clarification prompted by ChatGPT, I actually think I preferred the 2025 report format over this new one. So why didn’t ChatGPT 5.2 Thinking ask me any follow-up questions this time around? And that’s part of the frustration with tese tools; the way that they operate is still very much a black box, where you don’t understand how the tool is processing what you ask of it.

Then Versus Now: Gemini

The last comparison is between the Google Gemini report I produced on August 7th, 2025, and today’s report. One thing I noticed about the Aug. 7th report is how hard it tried to shoehorn in an overarching narrative into the final result, in a way that seemed a bit hamfisted, frankly. But the result was still a very detailed report with an extensive list of citations, comparable to today’s report. I prefer today’s version.


SECTION 4: Executive Summary and Ranking

This is going to be concise, I promise! Five points.

First, while we might be entering what Ethan Mollick calls “the agentic era,” my experience today shows that simply handing something off to an agent, as opposed to the back-and-forth conversation with a chatbot interface, does not always give the best result. In particular, Claude Cowork gave me terrible results, and eventually, I ran out of daily use credits to actually run the report I wanted in the first place.

Second, the user interface for these GenAI tools is awful and NON-intuitive. Hiding critical options like Deep Research under drop-down menus, and not making it clear what options have been selected when you do a text prompt, is a major problem. All three companies need to hire some good user interface/user experience staff. If I, with decades of computer experience and a goddamn computer science degree, can’t figure this shit out, God help the average non-technical user—and isn’t that what the point of generative AI is supposed to be, to make it easier for the user to do things??

Third, when these tools work, they are astoundingly good (the Gemini 3.0 Pro report with Deep Research turned on, and the Claude Opus 4.6 report with Research, Web Search, and Extended Thinking turned on). But when they don’t, they can still fail spectacularly (Claude Cowork). So you still have to be the human in the loop here, to figure out when you get a good result versus a bad one. What is frustrating is that all these GenAI tools operate in a black box, with only Gemini making some attempt at explaining what it was doing, as it was doing it.

Fourth, as Ethan himself said in his latest AI Guide:

The top models are remarkably close in overall capability and are generally “smarter” and make fewer errors than ever. But, if you want to use an advanced AI seriously, you’ll need to pay at least $20 a month (though some areas of the world have alternate plans that charge less). Those $20 get you two things: a choice of which model to use and the ability to use the more advanced frontier models and apps. I wish I could tell you the free models currently available are as good as the paid models, but they are not.

In other words, you get what you pay for. And sometimes, even the $20-a-month level isn’t enough, as seen with my experience on Feb. 18th with Claude (and yes, using the cutting-edge features does eat into your usage limits pretty quickly, as I learned to my chagrin).

Finally, I have found that the one of the best ways to see where the strengths and weaknesses of these GenAI tools is to enter the exact same text prompt into each of them, and then compare and contrast the results you get back. However, that approach is gonna cost you at least US$60 a month, so it might not be worth it to you. (And will I be doing this forever? No; at some point, I will just pick one or perhaps two tools and cancel my subscriptions to the rest of them.)

So, in this current round of testing, I would rank the results as follows (separating the results from Claude into the chatbot-generated report and the Cowork report):

  1. Google Gemini 3.0 Pro (with Deep Research turned on) provided me with a very detailed report with citations, as well as giving me a detailed play-by-play on how it was answering my query, which I really appreciated.
  2. Claude Opus 4.6 report (with Research, Web Search, and Extended Thinking turned on) also gave me a detailed report with citations, but several errors in the comparison chart made me question the overall quality and currency of the report. I also really hated how I had to futz around to get the results I really wanted!
  3. ChatGPT 5.2 Thinking is in a clear third place, in my opinion. Not bad, but not as detailed a result as Gemini and Claude provided.
  4. Claude Opus 4.6 Cowork, with perhaps the prettiest output but easly the least substantial result, using lower-quality sources of information, clearly failed at this task. For those reasons, I ranked it in last place. Ethan’s “Agentic Era” might be true for some applications, but certainly not this one!

I have found these little excursions into generative AI to be quite enlightening, and they have definitely given me some new ideas of topics to explore when I begin my research and study leave to write an OER about the metaverse. Hopefully, you found it enlightening, too. Please go subscribe to Ethan Mollick’s free Substack newsletter; he tends to update his AI Guide recommendations fairly regularly, and it’s really the best way too stay on top of a rapidly changing and evolving field!

ANNOUNCEMENT: My One-Year Research and Study Leave Project

Photo by Jaredd Craig on Unsplash

Open Educational Resources (OER) are teaching, learning and research materials in any medium—digital or otherwise—that either reside in the public domain or have been released under an open license that permits no-cost access, use, adaptation and redistribution by others with no or limited restrictions. While many think of OER as referring predominantly to open textbooks, OER includes a vast variety of resources, such as videos, images, lesson plans, coding and software, and even entire courses. In order for a resource to be considered open, it must fulfill the following criteria:

• Modifiable: The resource must be made available under an open license that allows for editing. Ideally, it should also be available in an editable format.

• Openly-licensed: The resource must explicitly state that it is available for remixing and redistribution by others. Some open licences may include restrictions on how others may use the resource (see: Creative Commons).

• Freely Available: The resources must be available online at zero cost.

—definition adapted from Introduction to Open Educational Resources, Open Education Alberta.

Not long ago, on my 62nd-birthday blogpost, I wrote:

…although it is not official official (and I really should wait until I get the official letter from university administration, which I was told should happen about the end of March), the University of Manitoba Libraries has approved my application to take a one-year Research and Study Leave (at full salary) to start later this year, where I am relieved of my regular academic librarian duties, and can work on a special project. Academic librarians at the University of Manitoba are members of the faculty union, and just like the professors, we have the right (and the opportunity) to pursue research. Again, more details later. I’ve only mentioned this to a couple of people so far, but I think I can share that much detail at this time.

Well, I am very happy to announce that it is now official official: I have formally been approved to take a one-year research and study leave, at full salary, from my employer, the University of Manitoba Libraries, to pursue a special project.

What is that special project, you may ask? Well, I’m just going to quote from my approved application form:

During my Research Leave, I will create a comprehensive Open Educational Resource (OER) addressing a critical gap in scholarly literature: a rigorous, pedagogically-sound introduction to virtual worlds, social virtual reality, and the metaverse, with particular emphasis on applications in higher education. This project builds directly on my expertise as the writer of a popular blog on the topic over the past eight years (https://ryanschultz.com), as well as the owner and moderator of an associated Discord server, representing over 700 members who are actively using various metaverse platforms. The research phase will involve a literature review, plus case study analysis of specific metaverse platforms. The OER will consist of several modules, including topics such as: the history of the concept of the metaverse; how the current wave of generative AI will impact the metaverse, etc. This project requires a dedicated research leave because the rapidly-evolving nature of the field requires intensive, concentrated research and focus. Released under a Creative Commons license, this resource will serve UM faculty and the global educational community, providing a freely-adaptable foundation for teaching, learning, and research.

Yep, that’s right folks, I am taking a full year off from my regular academic librarian duties to write a book about what I know best, and have been blogging about for many years now: virtual worlds, social VR, and the metaverse! (Throwing in a little bit about artificial intelligence and generative AI, as it applies to those topics.)

My leave runs from July 1st, 2026 through to June 30th, 2027, and the best part of it is, since it’s about the metaverse, I can literally work from anywhere: at home in Winnipeg, while visiting the rest of my family in Alberta, on the beach at Bora Bora (highly unlikely, although the Apple Vision Pro provides a suitable substitute in a pinch!), etc. The only rule is you have to vacate your current office at the university for whoever is filling in for you while you’re away on research leave, which seems pretty reasonable to me. However, I will be borrowing some of the VR/AR equipment which I had purchased on previous years’ travel and expense funds (T&E funds for short; essentially, extra money allocated to faculty and librarians for things like conference travel, books, computers, etc.):

Because part of this research work will involve social VR, I will have to move some virtual reality equipment purchased on previous years’ T&E funds from my office in Elizabeth Dafoe to my home. This equipment will be returned to my office after my Leave ends.

Oh, and I also have to promise that I will come back to my job at the University of Manitoba Libraries after my leave ends, which is fine, since I am planning to stay until I retire at age 65, in January 2029. This will, of course, be the last research leave I take before I do retire.

Best of all, after my OER is complete, anybody can use it for teaching, learning, and research purposes, including editing. remixing, and repurposing it (the exact rights will depend on which Creative Commons license I choose to publish it under).

Watch for updates on this project as I get closer to July 1st. Stay tuned!

Photo by Windows on Unsplash