The End of Summer and The Start of Work: MUDs and MOOs and Habitat!

An example of a MUD (Multi-User Dungeon), an early text-based virtual world

Yesterday, Labour Day, marks the traditional end of summer here in Canada. While my research and study leave commenced July 1st, 2026, almost all of my first two months were taken up with two monumental tasks: grieving the loss of my mother in late June, and decluttering and cleaning up my apartment. I needed to take my time and energy to work through the pain, and (literally) to throw out the crap in my life.

Now that that necessary work is (mostly) done, I can focus on my research and study leave. I know that I am a fortunate man, to be able to take the next ten months and do a deep-dive on a topic that already interests and excites me: virtual worlds, social VR/AR, and the metaverse.

Here’s just a teaser:

(And no, I am not going to commit to anything until I have settled a few key issues, such as what publishing platform I am going to use for my Open Educational Resource textbook; it would appear that the province-wide consortium using Pressbooks has shut down while I was grieving my mother, so for now all my writing is in Microsoft Word. Wish me luck!)

For those of you using screen readers, the text in the above image reads as follows:

CHAPTER 1: Before the Headsets: Text Worlds, MUDs, and the Dream of Cyberspace

While countless popular articles, books, and websites, and hundreds of academic papers, have been published about the metaverse (including those published before Neal Stephenson coined the term metaverse in his 1992 science-fiction novel Snow Crash, works which described the concept under other names), the nebulous and ever-evolving usage of the term has muddied rather than clarified things. What is the metaverse?

I think it’s best that we start with some back story. A little history lesson, explaining where this compelling but elusive idea(l) came from. Key components of the metaverse—avatars, virtual communities, and virtual economies—date back further than you might think.

(Please note; while I will be liberally sprinkling this text with my own experiences and opinions, this first chapter relies more on my research and reading, instead than my own personal experience. The real world/virtual world duality I mentioned in my preface to this book only began in March of 2007, when I first encountered Second Life, which will be the focus of the next chapter.)

In the Beginning Was the Word: Text-Based Virtual Worlds

Yep, you got it; I will doing a deep dive into MUDs and MOOs and other pre-graphical virtual worlds of the 1980s and 1990s! You gotta know where you came from before you know where you are now, and figure out where you’re going. So, I have a lot of reading ahead of me (not that I’ve ever minded that).

After that, I will be looking at the very first graphical virtual worlds that pre-dated Second Life (which will be the focus of chapter 2 of my book). Among these almost-forgotten early virtual worlds was Lucasfilms Habitat, which demonstrated a working avatar economy 17 years before Second Life came along.

Lucasfilms Habitat walked so Second Life could run!

Check out this eight-minute ad for Habitat from 1986, the year the platform launched in beta test, connecting users on their Commodore 64 microcomputers:

I figure all this research is probably going to take me most of the month, but I plan to have fun doing it!

UPDATE 7:00 p.m.: While searching my university library system’s online catalogue for an old 2003 book on virtual world design, I was overjoyed to discover that the author, Dr. Richard A. Bartle, has recently published a brand-new, completely revised and updated second edition of Designing Virtual Worlds! I’ve just started reading it and it is well-written, witty, and absolutely bang on for my research (he even includes several chapters on virtual world history). Perfect timing!

Here’s the citation if you want to buy it or obtain it from your local library:

Bartle, R. A. (2026). Designing Virtual Worlds: Volume I (Second edition). CRC Press. https://doi.org/10.1201/9781003689638

I suspect that I will be quoting Bartle’s book often in my own work, and making good use of his extensive bibliography. Here’s a particularly pertinent quote from the aforementioned history of virtual worlds:

Another reason that virtual world designers should appreciate the history of their art and profession is to counter the misguided belief that everything done in the past must be irrelevant because today’s virtual worlds are “different”. This is a surprisingly frequent but predictably monumental error. Brash designers coming in “to shake things up” may indeed shake things up – but not until they’ve repeated all the well‐known‐for‐decades errors that they didn’t think applied to their ideas because they gave virtual worlds a different label (“the Metaverse”) or a different interface (“VR”) or a different purpose (“education”).

—Bartle, R. A. (2026). Designing Virtual Worlds: Volume I (Second edition), p. 14

UPDATED! Yet Another Sign that the Metaverse Winter is Here: ENGAGE XR is to be Liquidated After Losing Its Biggest Customer

I have already noted that we appear to be in a period I am calling a “metaverse winter,” where virtual worlds in general, and social VR/AR in particular, are limping along or even shutting down. As further evidence of a period of retrenchment and reassessment, I learned that the long-running educational social VR platform ENGAGE XR has announced today that the company has lost a major customer, can no longer meet its financial obligations, and as a result is liquidating.

A message to shareholders posted to its website states:

Suspension of Shares

01 September 2026

ENGAGE XR Holdings Plc, a Metaverse / Spatial Computing technology company, announces further to its Final Results announced on 2 June 2026 that the Group’s largest customer which renewed its commercial arrangements with the Group in May 2026 has communicated to the Company that it will not be taking any licences going forward. The consequence of this is that the funds that were expected to be remitted to the Company pursuant to the contract will now not be received. 

Following a board meeting held on 31 August 2026 and having regard to the Company’s financial position, the board has unfortunately determined that it needs to proceed with a court approved liquidation in accordance with Irish Law. It is currently not expected that this process would provide any return for shareholders. 

Given the significant impact of the above on the Group’s financial position and prospects, the Company has requested a suspension in the trading of its shares on AIM which will become effective from 7:30 a.m. today. Further announcements will be made as appropriate.

This announcement contains inside information for the purposes of Article 7 of the Market Abuse Regulation (EU) 596/2014 as it forms part of UK domestic law by virtue of the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 (“MAR”), and is disclosed in accordance with the company’s obligations under Article 17 of MAR. 

I put on my trusty Valve Index, and paid ENGAGE a quick visit to take some screen shots (I had been in earlier this week).

A newer section called the School of AI, was announced as free for all to access all summer. I had paid a brief visit earlier, but I went back again.

There’s a teleporter sign at the entrance to whisk you to a portal where you can enter and engage (pun intended) in a conversation with a historical figure from the past, like Joan of Arc, Marie Curie, or Harriet Tubman.

I selected Joan of Arc, and entered the portal:

Immediately, I was immersed in a medieval forest outside a walled city, where Joan stood in her armour, next to a sign with some suggested starter questions:

(I didn’t stay very long; there were other visitors present, who had probably also heard the bad news about the liquidation, and I wanted to be sure that I could properly access these photos for this blog post so I could write up this report.)

This is a new and evolving situation. I do not know what will happen next, but I assume that at some point, you will not be able to access ENGAGE. So I would suggest if you want to pay a visit, do so soon. It’s up today, but it might not be up tomorrow!

The shocking news of ENGAGE’s liquidation, taken along with the demise of other metaverse platforms earlier this year— MeetinVR, Rec Room, Horizon Workrooms (with Horizon Worlds essentially dead as well)—clearly indicate that, as a whole, the concept of the metaverse is struggling to find a successful financial model. I fear that we are going to see more announcements of company pullbacks and shutdowns over the next twelve months.

The problem appears to be happening outside of social VR/AR, as well. For example, someone bought to my attention that even once-mighty Fortnite’s growth has stalled, leading to layoffs. In this April 2026 article, Tom Ffiske wrote:

Over the last few years, a string of immersive platforms has quietly shut down as dwindling player numbers and economic pressures have broken funding models. AltSpaceVR disappeared in March 2023. Rec Room has announced it will close in June 2026. And the VR version of Meta Horizon Worlds was announced for closure, before a last-minute reversal bought it a little more time. (If you listen carefully, you may hear the whistle of the guillotine swinging).

The trouble extends beyond VR headsets, too. Epic Games laid off around 1,000 people, largely because Fortnite’s growth had stalled. This is significant. Fortnite, one of the biggest games on the planet, the one every publisher has spent years trying to replicate… was struggling to grow. It is the lucrative, money-dripping pie that everyone sought after, picking up crumbs during the scramble. So much so that Sony tried to chase that model with a hard pivot toward multiplayer games, then quietly slowed down after Concord failed.

It’s not all bad news. Roblox is the obvious counterexample, and its success comes from a specific structural advantage: a creator ecosystem that produces content for free. Those creators build careers off the back of it, and the platform keeps going as a result. The strategy is similar to TikTok; let an army of young people make content for free, and let the platform grow via networking effects. The strategy works, as the platform hit 47mn concurrent players in 2025. It’s incredible what free talent can do.

So the problem is beyond VR. Across the board, most virtual hubs are shrinking. Players have stopped attending virtual concerts and conducting virtual meetings. They’ve moved on to other things (hello YouTube). So what happened?

On the VR side, there’s been a consistent pattern. Beyond the committed enthusiasts who genuinely love the technology, the wider market just hasn’t materialised as expected since 2021. Meta itself has noted that the number of Quest owners who continue using their headset long-term drops off after purchase. You can shift millions of VR headsets; but if player numbers drop off, then it’s much harder to monetise them over time.

But the bigger issue, in my view, is the astronomical costs of running these platforms. Tim Sweeney has said repeatedly that running Fortnite is one of the most expensive things Epic does, even accounting for the revenue it generates. “We’re spending significantly more than we’re making,” he said in a recent post. Reports differ, but Fortnite generates billions in revenue while costing billions to run. The Fortnite pie has a paper-thin crust.

What does all of this tell us, and what’s next? Well apart from Roblox, the era of the “behemoth platform” is over. In my view, the business case for building and maintaining a single massive virtual world — whether in VR or not — has proven weak. VR still has genuine traction in areas like training (and I have a soft spot for VR films), but as a social destination it hasn’t delivered. And as a virtual hub for players to play and hang, the economic case has proven to be incredibly hard to validate.

(Even though I would still classify Fortnite as more of a game than a virtual world, it has hosted virtual concerts in the past, so yes, the lines between games and metaverse platforms do get blurred a bit.)

As this is a breaking story, I expect that I will have updates for you. It saddens me to see ENGAGE go; I have been writing about this social VR platform since July of 2018 (you can see all my blogposts where I mention ENGAGE here).

UPDATE 7:26 p.m.: Okay, I’ve had an opportunity to let this news percolate a bit this evening, and I have some more thoughts I wanted to add.

For ENGAGE to choose this path after losing its “largest customer” means that, near the end, they probably didn’t have that many customers left, despite its website boasting “Over 200+ Enterprise and Education Clients Globally,” including some big corporate names, which must have been former customers:

Another thing I wanted to add was that, last November, I remember wandering around ENGAGE’s publicly-accessible venues and feeling that sadly rather familiar ghost-town feeling, that I had often felt before, in Sansar, and High Fidelity, and God knows how many other metaverse platforms which failed to take off.

The reason? Most likely because of the overall meh response by consumers to the virtual reality headsets required to visit these places (which Tom Ffiske points out in the quote above). It’s a theme I hope to discuss in more detail in the OER metaverse textbook I am researching and writing during my 12-month research and study leave: how so many companies (big and small) bet on the widespread adoption of virtual reality technology that did not happen, for various reasons.

Things must have been hectic, even frantic, behind the scenes over at ENGAGE headquarters. My heart goes out to any staff who will no doubt be impacted by this.

UPDATE 11:49 p.m.: Luke Williams of XR Beat has reported on the liquidation, including some public financial data that indicated ENGAGE’s difficulties:

ENGAGE XR’s June results listed 2026 renewals or new contracts with Optima Ed, Bank of America, University of Miami and a Fortune 500 technology company. The same announcement separately identified the latter three, before referring to a May renewal by its largest customer. The XR Beat was able to independently verify this as Optima Ed…

ENGAGE XR’s survival had already become dependent on customer payments arriving at the required time.

Revenue fell 43% to €1.94 million in 2025. The company recorded a €2.98 million pre-tax loss and €1.9 million operating cash outflow, while year-end cash fell from €3.57 million to €1.62 million.

Its June accounts warned of uncertainty over whether the group could continue operating. The expected payment from its largest customer formed part of the company’s cash forecast, with most anticipated 2026 revenue weighted towards the second half of the year.

ENGAGE XR hasn’t explained how long the platform will remain available, what will happen to existing customer content and licences or whether its technology could be sold during liquidation.

Optima Ed describes itself as “dedicated to forging partnerships with schools and parents to catalyze student learning and teacher development in the era of spatial computing,” with a focus on consulting within the K-12 community. And it sounds like there will be some other current customers who will definitely be impacted by whatever happens next.

UPDATE Sept. 3rd, 2026: This morning, I joined my metaverse friend Carlos Austin to explore ENGAGE XR. I could only stay for half an hour, but we did visit and have conversations with Winston Churchill and William Shakespeare in the above-mentioned School of AI section.

I already was well-aware of how well the new generative AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini could pretend to be a famous historical figure, and have a conversation with a user while staying completely in character, but adding the dimension of an immersive virtual world adds a whole new layer of presence and absorption.

Carlos was very good at throwing all kinds of questions (and a few curveballs!) at Winston and William, but both were able to conduct a very engaging conversation. (In one instance, as we were leaving, Carlos said “God save the Queen,” and Winston responded that he didn’t have a Queen, but said instead “God save the King!”)

The future is unknown, so I would urge everyone to visit ENGAGE XR as soon as you can, and try out the School of AI in particular. You can run it on desktop as well as on a variety of headsets (I have been able to access ENGAGE using both my Valve Index PCVR headset and my Meta Quest 3 headset.).

I went back into ENGAGE this afternoon for about an hour, chatting with a few more historical figures in the School of AI (like Leonardo da Vinci), and wandering around in both the Enterprise Plaza and the Education Plaza. Here are some more pictures (click on each to see it in a larger size):

The last two images in the gallery are from the Optima Ed world mentioned in Luke William’s article above.

UPDATE Sept. 5th, 2026: Over on the Educators in VR website and its associated Discord server, there has been much discussion and commentary about ENGAGE’s liquidation announcement. An editorial by Lorelle VanFossen published to the EDVR website Sept. 4th states in part:

The news that ENGAGE XR is entering liquidation is difficult for the many educators, students, institutions, creators, and organizations that have built learning communities in its virtual spaces.

For Educators in VR, since January 2019, ENGAGE XR has been more than an application or destination. It has been a place to teach, collaborate, experiment, present research, build virtual classrooms, host global gatherings, and demonstrate what becomes possible when learning is no longer confined to a rectangular screen.

First, let’s address the biggest question you all have. When is ENGAGE XR closing?

We don’t know that it will.

That’s the truth. I explain this more below, but the truth is, rumors of ENGAGE XR closing are early to the gossip mill. We don’t know. The staff doesn’t know. This was a court decision. There are many steps between that decision and closing.

For now, Educators in VR, and everyone at ENGAGE XR, is continuing as we have. Once an official decision has been made, it will be announced and time allotted for action steps.It is understandable to feel concern, disappointment, and even fatigue at the fear of another VR platform closing. We all feel it. This isn’t our first rodeo.

The immersive-technology sector has weathered repeated cycles of extraordinary enthusiasm followed by retrenchment, closures, layoffs, and uncertainty. Mozilla Hubs, AltspaceVR, and other social immersive platforms have ended or significantly changed their operations. Platforms such as Horizon Worlds and Spatial have also shifted strategy over time as companies navigate difficult financial, technical, and market realities.

Yet this moment does not erase what we have learned, built, or proven. It asks us to preserve it, prepare responsibly, and continue advocating for the learning futures we know are possible.

If you already understand what this means, go ahead and jump to our reminder to back up your virtual assets and consider your next platform choices.

This is only a partial quote of Lorelle’s entire editorial, and I would very strongly urge everybody to go over and read the entire thing. I have a great deal of respect for Lorelle and her opinions, and what she has to say about this situation and what it means is important reading. So go, do it!

And, from the EDVR Discord server, I learned that on September 2nd, 2026 (the day after ENGAGE XR’s liquidation announcement), Optima Ed (the customer whose pull-out from ENGAGE led to the current situation), has announced a partnership with the social VR platform Arthur. Hmmmm….

Also, Carlos Austin has posted the video he took of our excursion into ENGAGE XR on September 3rd (remember, I wasn’t there for all of it, and I must confess that I haven’t even watched all of this YouTube video myself yet!).

NEWLY UPDATED WITH VIDEO! Your Metaverse Is Too Small: My Keynote Presentation to the 2026 Virtual Worlds Best Practices in Education (VWBPE) Conference

Marie Vans (left) introduces me (right) as a keynote speaker at the 19th annual Virtual Worlds Best Practices in Education conference, held in the pioneering virtual world of Second Life (screen capture from the video at the end of this blog post)

As some of you might know, a while back I was asked by my librarian colleague (and fellow Second Life aficianado) Marie Vans if I would be willing to be one of the three keynote speakers during the 2026 Virtual Worlds Best Practices in Education (VWBPE) Conference, which is held every year in the pioneering virtual world of Second Life. I said yes (of course!). I never turn down an opportunity to give a presentation in my beloved Second Life. (I was asked to speak at the 2021 Virtual Ability Mental Health Symposium, giving a presentation on the topic of this blogpost on acedia during the pandemic, and in 2024, I gave a presentation on virtual world building in Second Life, in Second Life, to a graduate class in virtual world building and design, which was team-taught by a computer science professor and an interior design professor.) So, as you can see, this was not my first rodeo. 😉

The title of my presentation, which I gave as the keynote speech of the conference on its second day, Friday, March 20th, was Your Metaverse Is Too Small: How the Biases and Preconceptions of Virtual Worlds Hinder Their Use in Education. I was inspired by a keynote address at last November’s IMMERSIVE X conference by Andy Fidel, who titled her talk, held on the ENGAGE social VR platform: The State of the Metaverse in 2026. My talk therefore consisted of three parts as follows:

  • Quotes from Andy Fidel’s talk which I found inspiring and wanted to share (7 slides);
  • My initial, general observations about the metaverse (4 slides); and finally
  • A section titled Your Metaverse Is Too Small, where I discuss various ways our biases and preconceptions about virtual worlds and social VR/AR actually hinder their effective use in educational settings (with reference to Andy’s comments; 14 slides).

Yes, it’s a lot to cover in 45 minutes, but I did it! I’m just going to share my slides as-is, without any Creative Commons-type license this time around, since a lot of it is referring back to Andy Fidel’s ideas, which I found so inspirational in the first place. And yes, while the topics of these 14 slides in part 3 all sprang out of one particularly fevered brain dump of my ideas one evening, rather than relying on GenAI, I do freely admit that I fed my entire blog into a Google NotebookLM and asked it questions in order to create the content based on thirteen (yes, 13!) different ways that, quote: “your metaverse is too small!”

Your metaverse is too small because…

  • it has too steep a learning curve for new users
  • your platform has a poor fit-to-purpose
  • it lacks accessibility features (e.g. speech-to-text for the Deaf/HoH community)
  • it is poorly designed and/or Quality Assurance tested, and it causes VR sickness/nausea (more common among women than men)
  • it is soulless/designed by committee (hello Meta Horizon Worlds and Workrooms! Proof positive that you cannot will metaverse platforms into existence by executive fiat and the spending of billions of dollars.)
  • it requires a VR/AR/XR headset (I used two slides to discuss this controversial take; see below for more detail)
  • it relies on cryptocurrencies, NFTs, or some other form of blockchain (do I really have to explain this at this point?)
  • it has poor (or non-existent) safety and trust features and policies
  • it focuses on the product rather than the community
  • it has user data privacy issues/is based on surveillance capitalism (once again, hello Meta Horizon Worlds and Workrooms!)
  • you fail to market it properly (or, in many cases, fail to market it at all)
  • it is unfriendly to different cultures and subcultures (e.g. trans people, furries, etc.)
  • (another controversial one, explained further below) it refuses adult content

Now, before all you social VR adherents rise up with torches and pitchforks and tar and feather me for even daring to say “your metaverse is too small because it requires users to have a VR/AR/XR headset,” here are the two slides, plus speaker notes:

Your metaverse is too small because it requires you to use a virtual reality headset.

It is not a surprise that many of the most popular social VR platforms (e.g. Rec Room, VRChat) also allow for non-VR users to participate. The VR headset market still has not taken off. Even the best-selling Meta Quest line of wireless virtual reality headsets (which make up an estimated 70% of the global VR headset market) has sold only approximately 30 million units around the world, and many of those devices land up collecting dust after the initial novelty of the product wears off. Apple’s Vision Pro, launched to enormous fanfare, does not publish sales figures, but industry reporters said that the company shipped approximately 390,000 units in 2024 and approximately 90,000 units in 2025. VR hardware remains bulky, heavy, and uncomfortable for extended wear. Nausea continues to affect a significant proportion of users. A VR headset isolates the wearer from their physical surroundings and from the facial expressions of the people around them—an anti-social device, in practice, even when its purpose is socialization via social VR.

The PC-tethered VR headset market—the high-end, high-fidelity segment that many early social VR platforms had built toward—proved especially stagnant. The dream of millions of consumers owning gaming-grade PCs with tethered Oculus Rift or HTC Vive headsets never materialized. Even the shift to standalone headsets like the Meta Quest series failed to generate the consumer mass-market that had been anticipated. Sansar is perhaps the most instructive case study in the danger of building a platform around assumed headset adoption. Developed by Linden Lab—the company behind Second Life—Sansar was announced in 2014 and launched in beta in 2017, timed almost precisely to coincide with what seemed like the dawning of the VR era following Facebook’s acquisition of Oculus. But the bet on tethered PCVR headsets never paid off. In March 2020, Linden Lab sold Sansar to a little-known startup called Wookey and pivoted to focus on live music events and virtual concerts, attempting to find a more sustainable niche. That hasn’t worked, either. Sansar still exists, but it is only being kept alive by volunteers at this point.

Research on technology adoption consistently shows that devices requiring behavioral change—for example, for VR, wearing something on your face, isolating yourself from physical surroundings—face much higher adoption friction than technologies that integrate into existing habits. The iPhone and Android phones succeeded partly because they fit into already-established phone-carrying behavior. VR headsets require building a new behavior from scratch.

The failure of the last metaverse hype cycle does not mean that immersive technology has no future. What failed was the specific prediction that millions of people would soon be spending significant time in virtual worlds accessed primarily through VR headsets; that this would create platform-scale opportunities comparable to social media or mobile devices.

Don’t hate me for speaking facts. No VR/AR headset (even the Meta Quest line of headsets) has taken off in the way that iPhones/Android phones and tablets and smartwatches have. In particular, the developers of those platforms who bet the farm on widespread adoption of high-end tethered PCVR headsets (hello, Sansar and High Fidelity!) lost that bet badly; Sansar is essentially moribund, and High Fidelity is now closed (although it does live on in its successor social VR platforms Vircadia and Overte, which were based on HiFi’s open-source codebase, but are also not heavily used). This failure is one of the reasons why Second Life is still going strong (or strong enough) to endure and still be profitable for Linden Lab, for over 22 years now.

And speaking of SL…

I want to make one thing very clear: in some educational applications of the metaverse (especially those intended for children and teenagers, i.e. K-12 education), a ban on adult content is absolutely necessary.

However. As my speaker notes for this last slide in my presentation state:

However, in any institution of higher learning (e.g. a university). you will find faculty, staff, and students teaching about, learning about, and doing research on topics which may include controversial or adult topics. I have argued that one of the most significant strategic errors a metaverse platform can make is the outright refusal to host adult content (or do some other sort of heavy-handed sanitization of adult content, like imposing baked-on underwear on the base male and female adult avatars).

In my blog, I’ve pointed out that for some successful virtual worlds, adult communities are not just a niche—they are the economic and social engine that keeps the lights on. I have frequently cited Second Life as the prime example of a platform that understands the value of adult content. On my blog, I’ve noted that the adult-rated regions of Second Life generate a good portion of the platform’s revenue through land tier fees and the sale of virtual goods (clothing, skins, animations). In contrast, I wrote about Sansar’s early decision to strictly moderate content and its struggle to establish a clear policy on adult material. I argued that by trying to keep the platform “brand-safe” for corporate partners, they essentially “cut off their nose to spite their face,” alienating a potential demographic of creators and consumers who were ready to spend money on higher-fidelity adult experiences. And the corporate clients never came anyway!!

I believe that the ability to explore one’s identity—including its sexual or adult aspects—is fundamental to the metaverse experience. For example, both Second Life and VRChat tend to attract the trans community, giving them a way to experiment with how they represent themselves in a way that might be difficult or impossible to do in real life (particularly at a time when trans people are increasingly under attack in certain jurisdictions). Platforms that ban adult content often end up banning people by extension. If a platform’s moderation is too aggressive, it can lead to the marginalization of subcultures (like the furry community or the trans community) who use virtual worlds as a safe space for exploration. This aligns with Andy’s focus on “presence” and “feeling seen”. Andy argues that gathering spaces should be “smaller, weirder,” and more human. I have argued that by refusing to host adult content, platforms are choosing “corporate safety” over “human authenticity.” They are creating “noise” for brands rather than “spaces that matter” to real people.

One of my core arguments is that you cannot impose a culture on a virtual world; the users bring the culture with them. I’ve pointed out that in almost every successful social VR platform (like VRChat), “NSFW” content and communities exist regardless of official policies. Trying to ban these things is like trying to stop the tide with a broom. Platforms that fight their own communities on this issue usually lose the “heart and soul” that Andy Fidel says is required for a space to be successful. Andy speaks about “architecting belonging” and building spaces like cities. A real-life city has red-light districts, gay bathhouses, private clubs, and adult stores. By refusing to allow these “niche micro-communities” to exist, platform owners are failing to be the architects of a real society and are instead acting as corporate landlords of a sanitized shopping mall.

Okay, enough ranting. Here’s my slide presentation, which you can download to read the rest of my slides and my speaking notes:


Please note: while Philip Rosedale’s keynote speech on the first day of the Virtual Worlds Best Practices in Education conference on Thursday, March 19th has already been uploaded to the VWBPE YouTube channel, mine has not yet been uploaded to view. When it is, I will update this blogpost with a link to the video of my talk.

UPDATE March 30th, 2026: The video of my presentation in Second Life has now been uploaded to the VWBPE YouTube channel! Here it is (and I haven’t even watched it myself yet):

UPDATED! Generative AI Update, March 2026: My Updated Presentation on Artificial Intelligence and GenAI, Plus My First Thoughts on the Claude Add-In for PowerPoint, and Yet Another Head-to-Head Comparison Between Claude, Gemini, and ChatGPT

I am (as you can clearly tell by this absurdly long blogpost title) trying to do three related things here. If you want, you can skip to the very end, where there will be an executive summary, where I have some thoughts to share about (waves hands) all this.

First, I wanted to share an updated version of the original slide presentation on artificial intelligence and generative AI, which I shared in a December 2025 blogpost. I used to think that keeping track of the many metaverse platforms I blog about was a task similar to herding cats, but let me tell you, it was a breeze compared to trying to stay abreast of all the rapidly changing and accelerating developments in generative AI!

Keeping on top of developments in generative AI is like herding cats, where the cats are multiplying and mutating!
One of the updated comparison charts in my PowerPoint slide deck (see link below to download)

Below is my updated PowerPoint slide presentation, complete with my speaker notes, for you to download and use as you wish, with some stipulations. I am using the Creative Commons licence CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, which gives the following rights and restrictions):

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International

This license requires that reusers give credit to the creator. It allows reusers to distribute, remix, adapt, and build upon the material in any medium or format, for noncommercial purposes only. If others modify or adapt the material, they must license the modified material under identical terms.

BY: Credit must be given to you, the creator.

NC: Only noncommercial use of your work is permitted. Noncommercial means not primarily intended for or directed towards commercial advantage or monetary compensation.

SA: Adaptations must be shared under the same terms.

(The tool I used to determine the appropriate Creative Commons licence can be found here: https://creativecommons.org/chooser/.)

So, with all that said, here is my PowerPoint presentation (please click on the text link or the black Download button under the picture, not the picture itself):


NEW: Claude a just released add-ins for Microsoft Office

Second, today I installed a brand-new add-in from Anthropic’s Claude GenAI tool, which is supposed to work with Microsoft PowerPoint. This is an initial review of a very beta product.

And I have an actual real-world use case against which I will be trying out this new add-in: the design of an actual keynote presentation which I will be giving in a couple of weeks. (I am also using it in the third section, but in a different test of all three of ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini.)

Now, before I get into this, I should explain that I have tried in the past with all three GenAI tools on which I currently have paid accounts (OpenAI’s ChatGPT, Anthropic’s Claude, and Google’s Gemini) to create a PowerPoint slide deck presentation design—only to get highly disappointing and completely unusable results back. So I was not expecting much here, particularly as this is a still a research beta version of the PowerPoint add-in.

My initial prompt to the Claude add-in to Microsoft PowerPoint was:

Please create a new PowerPoint slide presentation design with the title of the presentation being: “Your Metaverse Is Too Small: How the Biases and Preconceptions of Virtual Worlds Hinder Their Use in Education.” The theme of the talk is educational uses of virtual worlds, social VR, and the metaverse in general. I want to have some nice background images to use in some of my slides, as well as a visually pleasing title slide. I’d prefer blue as a colour in the slide deck theme, thanks!

And Claude chugged away on my request, keeping my posted on what it was doing:

And it even prompted me to be sure I wanted to delete the Claude add-in help slide!

The set-up for the title slide took a long, loooong time, much longer than I would taken to click on the Designer button in the PowerPoint toolbar and just select one of the default options, and a colour scheme. Eventually, I just gave up on waiting and went off to work on another task, leaving Claude to beaver away. After fifteen minutes, I realized that I still had to explicitly okay the clearing of the original slide design (inset Homer Simpson “D’oh!“), which I did, so that the work could continue.

If I could summarize the result in one word, it would be: meh (again, shout-out to The Simpsons):

I mean, I could easily do better than this myself. And two dots do not make, as I asked for, “some nice background images to use in some of my slides, as well as a visually pleasing title slide.” Here’s my section title slide:

Again, extremely underwhelming, and frankly, not an improvement at all over my previous failed attempts to generate a PowerPoint slide presentation design using any of the GenAI tools (Claude, ChatGPT, or Gemini). Mind you, I have deliberately stayed away from using the image-generation tools in these products; I can spot a GenAI-produced image from a mile away by this point, having been playing around with these tools, off and on, since they first came out in 2022.

Claude continued to generate all the standard versions of PowerPoint slides in this theme, ending with a final slide that, I must confess, I kind of liked the look of (although, again, I would have preferred some sort of background image):

This is where the process got interesting, as I finally decided to stop having to manually okay each individual step, and just gave Claude carte blanche to do whatever it felt was best. (I mean, the worst that could happen was that it come up with something I hated so much that I threw it away and started over.)

Claude was still working away while I took my lunch break, giving feedback along the lines of “Build stunning title slide design.” 🙄 (I’ll be the judge of what’s considered stunning, Claude. Calm the fuck down.)

Here’s the final result, my “stunning” title slide (insert RuPaul’s Drag Race shade death rattle):

The addition of three pieces of clip art in the upper right corner of the slide, plus a few more bubbles/dots. So, yes, this is, once again, a complete fail. I will probably still use this as a basic slide design, but obviously I will be locating and using my own images to illustrate it. This is now the second new tool in a week (first Claude Cowork and now Claude PowerPoint add-in) which has utterly failed at the tasks given it. I am not impressed.


Third, and finally, thank God, I had much better luck was in issuing all three general-purpose GenAI tools the exact same text prompt, a technique I had used before here (and one which I found very useful in comparing and contrasting the responses):

I am writing a keynote presentation on the mistakes companies make when creating, designing, and marketing the following product category: virtual worlds, social VR/AR, and metaverse platforms in general. Please give me a list of failed or shut down metaverse platforms, along with reasons why they might have failed. Please cite both academic and industry sources of information in your answer.

In all cases, I used the latest models as specified in Ethan Mollick’s latest AI Guide:

  • ChatGPT’s GPT 5.2 Thinking with the Extended Thinking option;
  • Claude Opus 4.2 Extended Thinking with the Research option; and
  • Gemini 3 Thinking with the Deep Research option.

Unlike the last comparison, I’m not going to go into great detail on the results (because I will be using some of these results, once they are double-checked against more authoritative sources, in an actual keynote presentation I will be delivering later this month). Instead, I will my general overall impression of each report (and all three did provide a detailed report with citations).

Please note that I deliberately left it up to the specific GenAI tool to define what “failed” or “shut down” means, how far back and how thoroughly to search for failed platforms, and what metaverse platforms to include or exclude from its final report. As always, I find the differences between the reports to be an interesting way to compare and contrast the results, so below I will give some basic statistics:

GenAI Tool# Failed Platforms ListedTime Range of Failed Platforms# Citations in Final Report
ChatGPT152003 to 202623
Claude13(start dates not given) to 2023/”effectively failed, still limping along”30
Gemini92009 to 2024 (but some platforms had no timeline information given)33

While ChatGPT was the most thorough in listing failed metaverse platforms, and seems to have gone the furthest back in time (including There.com, which launched back in 2003!), it also had the fewest number of citations, and most of them were historical, platform-related announcements (e.g. a 2020 announcement of the shutdown of the then-social-VR platform High Fidelity by its CEO) rather than peer-reviewed academic journal articles (although there were a couple of those, too). While Claude had more citations, a review of those showed mostly blogs and news websites, with fewer references to actual academic research papers (probably because much of that content is locked behind academic publisher paywalls, although there were still quite a few academic references to free sources such as ResearchGate and PubMed Central/PMC; see the Claude report image below for one section which did focus on academic sources). Of the three, Gemini’s 33 citations used included the most resources which I would consider academic, from a good range of different publishers (as well as more informal websites). Interestingly, Gemini also included a list of resources which it looked at, but chose not to include in the final report, something which neither ChatGPT nor Claude offered! I thought that was particularly valuable, in case something else caught my eye to follow up on. Gemini for the win here.

Gemini was also notable for the strong, overarching narrative structure to its report, something which I had also noticed in previous queries using this GenAI tool. Gemini has clearly been trained well in telling a cohesive story! However, Claude was also notable for listing, in a separate section of its report, what it called “cross-cutting failure themes” in its 13 examined metaverse failures (which is definitely a phrase I will be stealing for my final keynote presentation!). By comparison, the final report from ChatGPT, while thorough, was jargon-heavy, poorly-formatted, and seemed to lack the final polish of its competitors. For example, there were three separate sections titled “failure themes and comparative analysis,” “theme-to-platform mapping,” (?!??) and “top 10 failures by primary cause.” It was, in my opinion, the poorest of the three reports generated, just in terms of sheer (lack of) organization and narrative. Again, Gemini for the win!

Gemini’s report had a strong, overarching narrative structure—something which I have noticed seems to be a particular strength of this GenAI tool, a sort of final overall polish to the text that ChatGPT, in particular, was lacking in its report (see below).
Claude’s report had a summary section titled “cross-cutting failure themes,” which I am definitely stealing for my keynote presentation!
Compared to the Gemini report, the ChatGPT report was jargon-heavy and poorly-formatted.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: So, here are my final thoughts.

  • It is getting harder and harder (in fact, almost a full-time job) to keep on top of what is fast becoming an arms race between the top three general-purpose generative AI tools (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini), not to mention an ever-growing legion of more narrowly-focused applications, which might be better at certain specific tasks, such as writing programming code or generating music.
  • While Claude seems to be good at putting new agentic (e.g. Claude Cowork) and add-in tools (Claude for PowerPoint) into the hands of its users first, my personal experience with these new tools has been very disappointing, even comically bad. However, Claude’s chatbot interface works well for generating detailed answers with citations (although slightly edged out by Gemini).
  • I am impressed by Gemini’s consistent ability to create a strong narrative structure within its generated reports, something in which ChatGPT in particular is noticeably lacking. It also came first in a key metric: actual citations to academic literature, not just freely-accessible websites (blogs and news articles).
  • If I were forced to rank the three GenAI tools by just this one head-to-head-to-head comparison (i.e. the third part of my blogpost), I would rank them as follows:
    • 1st: Google Gemini.
    • 2nd: Anthropic Claude.
    • 3rd. OpenAI ChatGPT.
  • Again, when these GenAI tools work, they work well (sometimes very well!), but they they fail, they fail spectacularly. Which, in my mind, is another reason why it is good to put these tools to the test regularly, and use them in real-life situations, so that you can learn what they are good and bad at!